We performed a comparison between Microsoft Defender for Identity and Proofpoint Identity Threat Defense based on our users’ reviews in five categories. After reading all of the collected data, you can find our conclusion below.
Features: Microsoft Defender for Identity has bidirectional sync capabilities, customized detection rules, and integration with other Defender components, while Proofpoint Identity Threat Defense offers real-time threat detection, user behavior analytics, and risk-based authentication. However, users have reported problems with false positives and the complexity of the reporting dashboard. Microsoft Defender for Identity has room for improvement in managing access controls, remediating threats, aligning with on-premise security, and enhancing threat intelligence. On the other hand, Proofpoint Identity Threat Defense needs a better user interface, integration with other security tools, and lower cost.
Service and Support: Microsoft Defender for Identity's customer service is varied, with some users reporting helpful and knowledgeable support while others experience delays and a lacking of technical knowledge. Conversely, Proofpoint Identity Threat Defense receives praise for its responsive and knowledgeable staff as well as consistent updates based on customer feedback.
Ease of Deployment: Microsoft Defender for Identity may have a more complicated initial setup than Proofpoint Identity Threat Defense, depending on the specific scenario. Whitelisting URLs and checking domain controllers' capacity are required by Microsoft, whereas Proofpoint provides an easy-to-use interface and customization options that integrate with other security tools.
Pricing: Microsoft Defender for Identity has a standard licensing fee without any additional costs, whereas Proofpoint Identity Threat Defense's pricing can differ based on the product type, features, and vendor.
ROI: Microsoft Defender for Identity is effective in preventing incidents and reducing management time, resulting in a positive return on investment. Proofpoint Identity Threat Defense's ROI depends on several factors and is not as clear-cut.
Comparison Results: Microsoft Defender for Identity is the better product compared to Proofpoint Identity Threat Defense. It offers comprehensive tools for measuring identity security, great security monitoring capabilities, bidirectional sync capabilities, and customized detection rules.
Microsoft Defender for Identity is a comprehensive security solution that helps organizations protect their identities and detect potential threats. It leverages advanced analytics and machine learning to provide real-time visibility into user activities, enabling proactive identification of suspicious behavior.
With its powerful detection capabilities, it can identify various types of attacks, including brute force, pass-the-hash, and golden ticket attacks. The solution also offers rich reporting and alerting capabilities, allowing security teams to quickly respond to incidents and mitigate risks. By continuously monitoring user activities and providing actionable insights, Microsoft Defender for Identity helps organizations strengthen their security posture and safeguard their sensitive data.
Proofpoint Identity Threat Defense is a comprehensive solution designed to protect organizations from identity-based cyber threats. Its primary use case is to detect and prevent attacks that exploit compromised user credentials. By analyzing user behavior and assessing the risk associated with each identity, it identifies and stops threats like account takeover, business email compromise, and insider threats.
The most valuable functionality of Proofpoint Identity Threat Defense lies in its ability to continuously monitor and analyze user activities across various channels, including email, cloud apps, and network logins. It leverages machine learning algorithms and advanced analytics to profile user behavior and detect anomalies that may indicate a potential threat. Additionally, it integrates with threat intelligence feeds and global threat databases to provide real-time threat intelligence and proactive defense.
This solution helps organizations by providing a multi-layered defense against identity-based attacks. By detecting compromised user accounts, it prevents unauthorized access to sensitive data and systems, reducing the risk of data breaches and financial losses. It also helps organizations meet regulatory compliance requirements by monitoring user activities and providing detailed reports for audits. Furthermore, by proactively identifying and stopping threats, it minimizes the overall impact on productivity and business operations.
Proofpoint Identity Threat Defense enables organizations to strengthen their security posture and safeguard their digital assets. It allows for more visibility into user behavior while mitigating risks associated with compromised identities and responding to threats in real-time. With its comprehensive capabilities, organizations can defend against the evolving threat landscape and protect their most valuable asset - their identities.
We monitor all Identity Threat Detection and Response (ITDR) reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.