Apache Kafka and Amazon SQS are prominent contenders in the distributed messaging and queue management category. While Kafka offers superior real-time streaming capabilities, Amazon SQS stands out for its integration and ease of use within the AWS ecosystem.
Features: Apache Kafka is well-regarded for its high throughput and distributed messaging capabilities, enabling efficient real-time streaming and persistence. It excels with robust support for partitioning, replication, and seamless integration with Spark, enhancing distributed processing. On the other hand, Amazon SQS provides serverless scalability, centering on reliable message delivery and security within AWS infrastructure. Its straightforward nature appeals to those looking for simplicity and ease in cloud environments.
Room for Improvement: The complexity of setting up and managing Apache Kafka is frequently mentioned, with improvements needed in user interface, management, and dependence on ZooKeeper. Notably, its setup and configuration can be daunting. Amazon SQS, although user-friendly, faces constraints like limited message size, lack of on-premise support, and the expense of scaling due to frequent polling.
Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: Apache Kafka offers deployment flexibility with on-premises, cloud, and hybrid options, though this often results in more complex management. Strong community support is available, supplemented by companies like Confluent offering professional services. Amazon SQS provides simpler cloud deployment with automatic scalability. Amazon’s robust support ensures quick responses to critical issues, contrasting with Kafka's community-driven approach.
Pricing and ROI: Apache Kafka's open-source nature presents cost savings with considerable ROI due to the absence of licensing fees, though enterprises might invest in paid support for added features. In contrast, Amazon SQS offers a pay-as-you-go model and a free tier for varied workloads, with potential cost increases in high-usage scenarios. Kafka often yields substantial financial benefits, while SQS’s costs may affect ROI at large scales.
Using Amazon SQS has led to increased productivity and reduced man-hour costs.
They meet their tasks effectively.
There is plenty of community support available online.
The Apache community provides support for the open-source version.
Amazon SQS is highly scalable, automatically managing itself based on the load.
Customers have not faced issues with user growth or data streaming needs.
With Amazon SQS, such maintenance is not needed, making it more reliable and secure.
Apache Kafka is stable.
It would be beneficial if there was a provision to configure and retain messages for longer than a week.
The performance angle is critical, and while it works in milliseconds, the goal is to move towards microseconds.
We are always trying to find the best configs, which is a challenge.
A more user-friendly interface and better management consoles with improved documentation could be beneficial.
On a scale of one to ten, where one is very cheap, I would rate the pricing as one.
The open-source version of Apache Kafka results in minimal costs, mainly linked to accessing documentation and limited support.
Its pricing is reasonable.
If there's a failure in the system after consuming a message, SQS's settings ensure the message is not deleted until confirmation.
Apache Kafka is effective when dealing with large volumes of data flowing at high speeds, requiring real-time processing.
It allows the use of data in motion, allowing data to propagate from one source to another while it is in motion.
Amazon Simple Queue Service (SQS) is a fully managed message queuing service that enables you to decouple and scale microservices, distributed systems, and serverless applications. SQS eliminates the complexity and overhead associated with managing and operating message oriented middleware, and empowers developers to focus on differentiating work. Using SQS, you can send, store, and receive messages between software components at any volume, without losing messages or requiring other services to be available. Get started with SQS in minutes using the AWS console, Command Line Interface or SDK of your choice, and three simple commands.
SQS offers two types of message queues. Standard queues offer maximum throughput, best-effort ordering, and at-least-once delivery. SQS FIFO queues are designed to guarantee that messages are processed exactly once, in the exact order that they are sent.
Apache Kafka is an open-source distributed streaming platform that serves as a central hub for handling real-time data streams. It allows efficient publishing, subscribing, and processing of data from various sources like applications, servers, and sensors.
Kafka's core benefits include high scalability for big data pipelines, fault tolerance ensuring continuous operation despite node failures, low latency for real-time applications, and decoupling of data producers from consumers.
Key features include topics for organizing data streams, producers for publishing data, consumers for subscribing to data, brokers for managing clusters, and connectors for easy integration with various data sources.
Large organizations use Kafka for real-time analytics, log aggregation, fraud detection, IoT data processing, and facilitating communication between microservices.
We monitor all Message Queue (MQ) Software reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.
