AWS Secrets Manager vs HashiCorp Vault comparison

Amazon Web Services (AWS) and HashiCorp are both solutions in the Enterprise Password Managers category. Amazon Web Services (AWS) is ranked #3 with an average rating of 8.8, while HashiCorp is ranked #4 with an average rating of 8.3. Amazon Web Services (AWS) holds a 24.5% mindshare in EPM, compared to HashiCorp’s 14.8% mindshare. Additionally, 100% of Amazon Web Services (AWS) users are willing to recommend the solution, compared to 88% of HashiCorp users who would recommend it.

AWS Secrets Manager

Read 13 AWS Secrets Manager reviews

12,930 Views
11,500 Comparison Views

100% willing to recommend

HashiCorp Vault

Read 16 HashiCorp Vault reviews

12,967 Views
8,606 Comparison Views

88% willing to recommend

AWS Secrets Manager

HashiCorp Vault

Comparison Buyer's Guide

Download the report

Executive SummaryUpdated on Oct 8, 2024

HashiCorp Vault and AWS Secrets Manager compete in the secrets management category. HashiCorp Vault gains an advantage with pricing and support, while AWS Secrets Manager is preferred for advanced features, making it appealing despite higher costs.

Features: HashiCorp Vault is valued for robust security, versatile integration capabilities, and cost-effectiveness. AWS Secrets Manager is noted for seamless integration within AWS services, ease of automation, and the streamlined AWS ecosystem experience.

Room for Improvement: HashiCorp Vault can improve simplify its setup and reduce management complexity. AWS Secrets Manager could benefit from improved third-party integration and broader support. Users suggest usability enhancements for HashiCorp Vault.

Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: Both solutions offer comprehensive deployment models. AWS Secrets Manager provides smoother deployment due to AWS integration, while HashiCorp Vault users benefit from support geared towards customization. AWS Secrets Manager benefits from AWS's extensive support network.

Pricing and ROI: HashiCorp Vault is commended for cost-effectiveness, providing good ROI with careful management. AWS Secrets Manager is more expensive, but its comprehensive AWS integration and features justify the cost with positive ROI. HashiCorp Vault's lower initial costs are contrasted by AWS Secrets Manager's long-term value in the AWS ecosystem.

To learn more, read our detailed AWS Secrets Manager vs. HashiCorp Vault Report (Updated: October 2024).

Buyer's Guide

AWS Secrets Manager vs. HashiCorp Vault

October 2024

Download the complete report

Helped 816,406 peers since 2012

Categories and Ranking

AWS Secrets Manager

Ranking in Enterprise Password Managers

3rd

Average Rating

8.8

Number of Reviews

Ranking in other categories

No ranking in other categories

HashiCorp Vault

Ranking in Enterprise Password Managers

4th

Average Rating

8.2

Reviews Sentiment

8.5

Number of Reviews

Ranking in other categories

No ranking in other categories

Mindshare comparison

As of November 2024, in the Enterprise Password Managers category, the mindshare of AWS Secrets Manager is 24.5%, up from 23.4% compared to the previous year. The mindshare of HashiCorp Vault is 14.8%, down from 18.2% compared to the previous year. It is calculated based on PeerSpot user engagement data.

Enterprise Password Managers

Q&A Highlights

Netanya Carmi

Content Manager at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)

Dec 12, 2021

Which is better - HashiCorp Vault or AWS Secrets Manager?

yet to learn both

See all answers

Featured Reviews

ManuelTorres

Cyber security senior engineer at International Airlines Group (IAG)

Simplifies and secures secret management within the AWS ecosystem, though it could enhance integration capabilities with external platforms

AWS Secrets Manager has streamlined our processes for managing secrets and their lifecycle. We typically handle everything through automation, following a predefined approach. When we undertake our developments, we seamlessly integrate the process into our workflows. Essentially, our secrets require minimal intervention; they are automatically managed by the system itself. This ensures smooth operations without the need for manual intervention. We integrate this tool with various AWS services, utilizing AWS Secrets Manager specifically for AWS resources. Any application, service, or deployment within AWS leverages Secrets Manager whenever it requires access to it.

Read full review

KishoreKumar1

Architect at Accenture

Useful for machine-to-machine communication and has secret engine feature

The feature I find most beneficial in HashiCorp Vault is the secret engine. It integrates smoothly with many applications, making it easy to set up and implement quickly. This allows you to test it easily and see good results rapidly. When you integrate an internal API or application, it quickly manages that application's secrets. The access management feature in HashiCorp is great, especially if you are considering situations where users are getting onboarded. They can manage their passwords themselves, and it integrates well with Active Directory or any other directory services. This is particularly useful for user management and applications that communicate with each other without human intervention.

Read full review

Quotes from Members

We asked business professionals to review the solutions they use. Here are some excerpts of what they said:

Pros

"It's highly scalable, so I'd rate it a ten out of ten."

"The most valuable feature of AWS Secrets Manager is its seamless integration with various AWS services."

"The most valuable feature of AWS Secrets Manager is the ability to keep data secret and assign access permissions to people to grant or restrict access."

"The most valuable feature is security."

"The API is fine and works well."

"The solution is very scalable."

"The most valuable feature is the management of credentials."

"All our workloads are running on AWS, so integration with our workload is much easier on AWS Secrets Manager than going with another solution such as Thycotic."

More AWS Secrets Manager pros

"It can still be configured by a separate team other than developers. That's why I think it's more secure."

"We were using it because we have compliance requirements around secret management. Having a secure vault and encrypting data was an additional requirement. When we looked at it first, we were just looking for a vault, like a lockbox. The greatest benefit of HashiCorp is its ability to manage encryption on the fly. It provides encryption of data at rest, in use, in transit, on the fly, and linked with applications, which was really attractive."

"This solution is easy to use and to integrate."

"The tool's dynamic rotation of the password credentials is good."

"It is a good product to consider for companies who are looking to build on-premise or hybrid infrastructure."

"It's stable. I would rate the stability a nine out of ten."

"The most valuable feature of HashiCorp Vault is the management of tickets in the pipeline."

"It is user-friendly and easy to implement from any application point."

More HashiCorp Vault pros

Cons

"The price of the solution could improve."

"An area for improvement in AWS Secrets Manager could be expanding integration options beyond AWS services."

"If you add one more layer of security to AWS Secrets Manager, even the programmer will not be able to see the secrets."

"We occasionally have problems with rate limits, although that is a problem more generally with AWS."

"AWS Secrets Manager could support hybrid infrastructure."

"There is a need for better environmental implementation, such as having a security fund as a solution."

"The solution's initial setup process is complicated."

"If you don't have enterprise support, then you will not be able to get through to them to get the help. It is not only applicable to AWS Secrets Manager. It is also applicable to any service on AWS."

More AWS Secrets Manager cons

"We could use more documentation, primarily to do with integrations."

"The product needs to improve its customization. It should be also more like easy to plug and play."

"I would like to see better integration of HashiCorp Vault with SAP products."

"A drawback for some clients who have to be PCI compliant is that they still need to use and subscribe to an HSM (Hardware Security Module) solution."

"In terms of features, the only thing that I found a little bit hinky was that there was no revocation or deletion on the model we were using. Once in a financial year, a client interacts, and you pay for that client for the year. So, there are just little things like that in the pricing. There should be more clarity around the end of the key. I know there is no system like this. They all are the same. I tested Microsoft, Google, and some others, and none of them really want you to delete a key, which makes sense. You delete a key, and you lose everything that it has wrapped or encrypted, but it's actually just a language. Deletion isn't really deletion. It's really revocation, but overall, HashiCorp Vault ticked all the boxes for us, and I couldn't fault it."

"The product is complicated to install."

"There could be a plugin for the database to change the secret automatically. It would be an efficient feature for password security."

"The technical support was hard to get a hold of and lacking in service."

More HashiCorp Vault cons

Pricing and Cost Advice

"I don't believe there is a license cost for the solution."

"The solution is expensive."

"The cost is somewhat high."

"We've observed that AWS Secrets Manager pricing is based on a per-secret-per-month model. As a result, we prefer to divide our secrets into individual pieces to increase security and grant specific access permissions to certain secrets, systems, or individuals. However, this approach results in higher costs. Therefore, we have been exploring ways to combine our secrets into groups to reduce expenses and simplify management. Nonetheless, we acknowledge that this issue may not be related to the secret manager's functionality."

"We purchase a monthly license for the product."

"I am using the open-source version of Vault and I would have to buy a license if I want to get support."

"The product is expensive."

"It could do everything we wanted it to do and it is brilliant, but it is super pricey. To be fair to HashiCorp, we drove the price up with our requirements around resiliency. Because of the nature of our company, we don't really operate in the cloud."

"The solution's cost is reasonable."

"In my case, the open-source version works well. It's advisable for small to medium-scale organizations, but for large-scale organizations, you should go with the enterprise version."

"The AWS version is much cheaper than HashiCorp Vault."

See which vendors are best for you

Use our free recommendation engine to learn which Enterprise Password Managers solutions are best for your needs.

See recommendations

816,406 professionals have used our research since 2012.

Answers from the Community

Netanya Carmi

Content Manager at PeerSpot (formerly IT Central Station)

Dec 12, 2021

Which is better - HashiCorp Vault or AWS Secrets Manager?

See 2 answers

Kmk Kan

Works at Zerto

Nov 23, 2021

yet to learn both

Read full answer

Dovid Gelber

Tech blogger

Dec 12, 2021

HashiCorp Vault was designed with your needs in mind. One of the features that makes this evident is its ability to work as both a cloud-agnostic and a multi-cloud solution. As a cloud-agnostic solution, HashiCorp Vault allows you to be flexible in the cloud infrastructure that you choose to use. It is completely compatible and integratable with a myriad of different platforms. You can determine what you want to use and HashiCorp Vault will function without issue, regardless of what you choose. If you are using HashiCorp Vault as a multi-cloud solution, then you have an even greater number of platform options. You will be able to mix and match which cloud platforms you like to use to customize your data protection. The only limits on your customization will end up being your imagination. HashiCorp Vault’s user interface is simple for you to both use and navigate. The UI was designed to be basic enough for users to manage without forcing an organization to spend a great deal of time and resources having to train employees in its use. It might be a little confusing for employees when they start using it. However, once they have used it for a little while they will be proficient in its use. Should an organization choose to invest in training employees in the use of this UI, the required investment will be minimal. AWS Secrets Manager is an extremely user-friendly solution. It is intuitive in its design, which makes it a valuable product. However, AWS Secrets Manager lacks the level of cloud flexibility that HashiCorp Vault offers. Conclusion: While AWS Secrets Manager is a fairly competent product, we found HashiCorp Vault to be superior. HashiCorp Vault‘s greater flexibility and integration capabilities make it the more robust solution.

Read full answer

Top Industries

By visitors reading reviews

Computer Software Company

16%

Financial Services Firm

14%

Manufacturing Company

Insurance Company

Financial Services Firm

20%

Computer Software Company

16%

Manufacturing Company

Government

Company Size

By reviewers

Large Enterprise

Midsize Enterprise

Small Business

Questions from the Community

Which is better - Azure Key Vault or AWS Secrets Manager?

Azure Key Vault is a SaaS solution. You can easily store passwords and secrets securely and encrypt them. Azure Key Vault is a great solution to ensure you are compliant with security and governanc...

See all answers

Which is better - HashiCorp Vault or AWS Secrets Manager?

See all answers

What do you like most about AWS Secrets Manager?

The most valuable feature of AWS Secrets Manager is its seamless integration with various AWS services.

See all answers

What do you like most about HashiCorp Vault?

See all answers

What is your experience regarding pricing and costs for HashiCorp Vault?

The enterprise version would require considering factors like the level of support needed, the amount of secret data being stored, and replication needs. But in my case, the open-source version wor...

See all answers

What needs improvement with HashiCorp Vault?

In my opinion, HashiCorp Vault could improve its user interface. Right now, they don't offer much in terms of a graphical interface, which means you usually have to manage things manually through A...

See all answers

Comparisons

Azure Key Vault vs AWS Secrets Manager

Compared 70% of the time

1Password vs AWS Secrets Manager

Compared 5% of the time

Delinea Secret Server vs AWS Secrets Manager

Compared 2% of the time

CyberArk Privileged Access Manager vs AWS Secrets Manager

Compared 2% of the time

Bitwarden vs AWS Secrets Manager

Compared 1% of the time

More AWS Secrets Manager Competitors

Azure Key Vault vs HashiCorp Vault

Compared 25% of the time

Keeper vs HashiCorp Vault

Compared 10% of the time

Delinea Secret Server vs HashiCorp Vault

Compared 9% of the time

Bitwarden vs HashiCorp Vault

Compared 9% of the time

BeyondTrust Password Safe vs HashiCorp Vault

Compared 5% of the time

More HashiCorp Vault Competitors

Product Reports

Buyer's Guide

Enterprise Password Managers

October 2024

Download AWS Secrets Manager product report

Buyer's Guide

HashiCorp Vault

November 2024

Download HashiCorp Vault product report

Learn More

Amazon Web Services (AWS)

HashiCorp

Overview

AWS Secrets Manager helps you protect secrets needed to access your applications, services, and IT resources. The service enables you to easily rotate, manage, and retrieve database credentials, API keys, and other secrets throughout their lifecycle.

HashiCorp Vault is a cloud-agnostic solution used for security and secret management. Its valuable features include integration with other HashiCorp tools, token sharing, open source nature, cloud agnosticism, and on-the-fly encryption management.

The solution provides encryption of data at rest, in use, in transit, on the fly, and linked with applications. It is free to use, and the interface is simple to navigate. HashiCorp Vault has helped organizations with its multiple authentication methods and RESTful API.

HashiCorp Vault Features

Data encryption: The solution is capable of encrypting and decrypting data, and will not store it. Organizations’ security personnel define their own encryption protocols; developers can store the encrypted data where they choose and are not obligated to design specific encryption processes.
Robust secrets: For systems such as AWS or SQL databases, Vault is able to generate secrets automatically. HashiCorp Vault is able to generate AWS keypairs with all the appropriate permissions when necessary, and when the approved time expires, will nullify them.
Secure secret storage: Any type of value or key secrets can be stored in the Vault. The Vault automatically encrypts the desired secrets before recording them into persistent storage, keeping them safe and secure. Users can record data using HCP Vault’s Consul service or disk, or choose from other options.
Nullification: Vault is able to nullify single secrets or all secrets from a particular group or specific user. This process is integral in securing systems in the event of an attack or inappropriate access.

Reviews from Real Users

“The greatest benefit of HashiCorp is its ability to manage encryption on the fly. It provides encryption of data at rest, in use, in transit, on the fly, and linked with applications, which was really attractive. The lifecycle of a key is so easy to manage in terms of rotating, revoking, and issuing. They have different auth methods, and I tried all different auth methods. It is seamless.”- Project Manager at a comms service provider.

“The most valuable feature of HashiCorp Vault is that it's an open source solution. Second, it's cloud-agnostic, so it's very easy to maintain and control, which is why we prefer HashiCorp. “ - Mohamed A., Lead DevOps Engineer at Etisalat.

Sample Customers

Autodesk, Clevy, Stackery

Adobe, SAP Ariba, Citadel, Spaceflight, Cruise

Buyer's Guide

AWS Secrets Manager vs. HashiCorp Vault

October 2024

Free Report: AWS Secrets Manager vs. HashiCorp Vault

Find out what your peers are saying about AWS Secrets Manager vs. HashiCorp Vault and other solutions. Updated: October 2024.

DOWNLOAD NOW

816,406 professionals have used our research since 2012.

See our AWS Secrets Manager vs. HashiCorp Vault report.

See our list of best Enterprise Password Managers vendors.

We monitor all Enterprise Password Managers reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.