Executive SummaryUpdated on Dec 16, 2024
AWS Secrets Manager and One Identity Password Manager are competing products in the realm of secrets and password management. AWS Secrets Manager is favored for its integration within the AWS ecosystem, making it preferable for businesses utilizing AWS services extensively.
Features: AWS Secrets Manager offers seamless integration with AWS services, along with automatic rotation, enhancing both security and operational efficiency. It supports cross-account access, which is crucial for maintaining secure environments. One Identity Password Manager provides comprehensive password lifecycle management, focusing on reducing helpdesk workloads. It offers password self-service and resets while ensuring compliance with enterprise-level password policies.
Room for Improvement: AWS Secrets Manager could improve by offering more flexible integration options outside the AWS ecosystem, enhancing its usability for diverse tech environments. Greater customization options in secret rotation policies may be beneficial. More streamlined API interfaces could enhance user experience. One Identity Password Manager could benefit from more user-friendly installation processes, improved integration with non-standard applications, and enhanced out-of-the-box multi-factor authentication features to compete with emerging security standards.
Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: AWS Secrets Manager ensures quick deployment within AWS environments, supported by comprehensive documentation and responsive support. One Identity Password Manager requires more initial setup, which can be offset by its flexibility in complex enterprise settings and tailored customer support that meets specific deployment needs.
Pricing and ROI: AWS Secrets Manager provides a cost-effective solution for businesses centered on AWS, with straightforward pricing based on API requests and secrets stored, facilitating predictable budgeting. One Identity Password Manager may have a higher initial investment but offers significant ROI through decreased administrative expenses and advanced security measures, making it appealing for larger organizations with a focus on security and compliance.
