Camunda and AWS Step Functions compete in the workflow automation space, with Camunda offering strong process modeling support and AWS Step Functions providing seamless integration with AWS services. AWS Step Functions seems to have an advantage for AWS-centric architectures due to its tight service integration and graphical interface.
Features: Camunda offers robust support for BPMN, CMMN, and DMN standards, flexible customization, and a solid open-source foundation. It is well-suited for process modeling with limited programming knowledge and includes advanced features like REST API integration. AWS Step Functions provides a highly integrated experience with AWS services, advanced workflows, and an intuitive graphical design interface. Its strength lies in orchestrating processes across different AWS services.
Room for Improvement: Camunda could enhance its UI/UX, improve its documentation for complex integrations, and address performance challenges in large-scale deployments. AWS Step Functions faces limitations with payload size, lacks clear pricing, and relies heavily on AWS infrastructure, potentially complicating multi-cloud strategies.
Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: Camunda offers diverse deployment options, including on-premises, hybrid, and public cloud, but the support could be more robust according to users. AWS Step Functions is tightly integrated with the AWS public cloud ecosystem, receiving positive feedback for its high-level support, though it might lack flexibility for users outside the AWS environment.
Pricing and ROI: Camunda's open-source model provides cost benefits, attracting startups, although support and enterprise features are additional expenses. Pricing is generally seen as reasonable but varies with process instances. AWS Step Functions pricing is usage-based and can be challenging to predict, potentially surprising users as usage scales. Both systems offer ROI, contingent on existing infrastructure and use cases.
I use enterprise support, which is excellent, providing responses within fifteen minutes.
AWS provides the best support, followed by Microsoft, and then Google.
They provide better support for the enterprise edition.
They can handle multiple simultaneous requests effectively.
Camunda offers a high level of scalability, especially when using its SaaS model, which manages and scales implementations automatically.
ECS and Fargate make horizontal scalability very easy.
If one zone fails, others handle the demand, ensuring high availability.
There haven't been any significant outages in my experience with Camunda.
More open documentation would be beneficial to understand the deployment process better and facilitate easier setup.
There is an issue where, in some situations, I need to scale up by observing both CPU and memory usage of containers, yet under the current options available at Amazon, this is not possible.
Pricing for Step Functions is very cheap.
The cost is average, provided it is configured correctly.
AWS pricing is very competitive compared to Azure and cheap compared to Google.
There is a licensing cost for using the SaaS model and Enterprise edition of Camunda.
Step Functions provide seamless integration with AWS services, which enhances the speed of application development.
AWS Step Functions offers advanced workflows that save time and enhance efficiency by reducing delays and ensuring consistent orchestration among various services.
ECS also allows for horizontal scalability with thresholds that can be configured for CPU or memory.
AWS Step Functions enables orchestration of complex workflows, parallel task execution, and seamless integration with AWS services, simplifying ETL automation and data pipeline management.
With AWS Step Functions, developers streamline task automation and ensure smooth microservices orchestration. It simplifies development and manages interdependencies, validates data, and integrates AWS services for cost-effective workflows. It offers a user-friendly graphical interface for creating pipelines, scalable parallelization via the "map" state, control over historical events, and visualization with JSON. Enhanced by a dashboard-like view, it aids in visual workflows and debugging.
What are the most valuable features?In specific industries such as finance, healthcare, and e-commerce, enterprises implement AWS Step Functions to manage data pipelines, orchestrate microservices, and automate complex ETL jobs. They benefit from seamless integration with AWS services, enhanced data validation, and streamlined development, resulting in efficient and cost-effective workflows tailored to their operational needs.
Camunda enables organizations to orchestrate processes across people, systems, and devices to continuously overcome complexity and increase efficiency. A common visual language enables seamless collaboration between business and IT teams to design, automate, and improve end-to-end processes with the required speed, scale, and resilience to remain competitive. Hundreds of enterprises such as Atlassian, ING, and Vodafone orchestrate business-critical processes with Camunda to accelerate digital transformation. To learn more visit camunda.com.
We monitor all Business Process Management (BPM) reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.
