What is our primary use case?
Our primary use case for this solution is identity and access management within our organization's hybrid cloud environment. We have a multinational presence across 12 countries, with around three thousand employees worldwide. Entra ID plays a pivotal role in streamlining user onboarding and offboarding processes, ensuring secure access to our resources.
Our environment is characterized by a blend of on-premises and cloud-based services, and Entra ID seamlessly integrates with our Azure tenant. It allows us to efficiently manage user identities, enforce authentication and authorization policies, and implement multifactor authentication for enhanced security.
Moreover, we leverage Entra ID's capabilities to maintain compliance with specific regulations, such as those in Germany, where mailbox access for departed employees requires careful management. Entra ID's security features, including Azure Information Protection integration, provide an additional layer of protection against evolving cyber threats.
How has it helped my organization?
Microsoft Azure Entra ID has been a transformative addition to our organization, bringing a multitude of benefits and enhancements across various facets of our operations. Here are the key ways in which Entra ID has made a significant difference:
Unified User Access and Seamless Experience:
Entra ID provides a unified interface for managing user access, offering an exceptionally user-friendly experience. Users can effortlessly access a wide range of applications, both cloud-based and on-premises, using a single set of credentials. The Azure portal serves as a true portal, creating a distinct realm for users while maintaining a user-friendly interface. Single Sign-On (SSO) configuration simplifies the login process, allowing users to use a single ID for multiple applications. This streamlined approach, coupled with multifactor authentication, ensures a secure and convenient login experience, especially important in today's remote work environment.
Efficient Policy Management:
One of the standout features of Entra ID is the ease with which Azure policies and conditional access can be applied to enhance security. The EntraID admin center serves as a central hub for cloud-based identity and access management, offering a wide array of features that not only enhance security but also promote collaboration and productivity within the organization.
Modern Authentication Protocols:
Entra ID employs modern authentication protocols like OpenID Connect, which are well-suited for web and mobile users. This is especially crucial in an era where remote work and mobile device usage are prevalent. It represents a significant improvement over the traditional Windows Active Directory, which relied solely on Kerberos and NTLM.
Hybrid Capabilities:
Entra ID's support for hybrid scenarios is invaluable. It caters to the preferences of employees who still rely on on-premises solutions while leveraging the advantages of the cloud. This flexibility in a hybrid environment is a substantial benefit.
Conditional Access for Enhanced Security:
Conditional access policies, akin to "if-then" scenarios, provide granular control over access conditions. These policies evaluate login attempts based on factors such as user location, device health, and more. This ensures that access is granted only under specific, predefined conditions, significantly bolstering security.
Role-Based Access Control (RBAC):
Entra ID offers a robust RBAC system that allows precise management of access permissions. Custom roles can be created, granting users only the necessary permissions, enhancing security without overexposure.
Cost-Effective Scalability:
The cost-effectiveness of Entra ID is notable. It offers a free option, making it accessible to organizations of various sizes. Premium plans unlock advanced features, such as identity protection and advanced threat detection, providing excellent value for the investment.
Enhanced User Experience:
Entra ID has substantially improved the user experience. Account creation and provisioning are straightforward, even more streamlined than traditional Windows Active Directory. This inclusive process involves licensing, role, and permission configuration, all within a unified interface.
Microsoft Azure Entra ID has significantly enhanced our organization's security, user experience, and efficiency. Its modern authentication, conditional access, and RBAC capabilities, along with its support for hybrid environments, make it a valuable addition to our IT ecosystem. Moreover, the cost-effectiveness of Entra ID and its role in simplifying identity and access management have further solidified its value proposition. Our users are more satisfied than ever, thanks to the improvements brought about by this powerful solution.
What is most valuable?
The standout features of Microsoft Entra ID, for me, revolve primarily around its robust security measures. As someone deeply invested in cloud security, these aspects have proven to be exceptionally valuable.
Conditional Access Policies: The ability to formulate and enforce conditional access policies is a game-changer. It allows us to implement highly granular access control, considering factors like user location, device health, and authentication methods. This level of flexibility ensures that access to critical resources is granted only under the appropriate circumstances, enhancing our security posture significantly.
Identity Protection: Microsoft Entra ID's identity protection capabilities are commendable. They assist us in safeguarding user identities, reducing the risk of unauthorized access and identity-related security breaches. The peace of mind that comes with knowing our identities are well-protected is invaluable.
Threat Intelligence: Real-time threat intelligence provided by Entra ID equips us with the necessary tools to stay ahead of emerging security threats and vulnerabilities. In a rapidly evolving threat landscape, having this information at our fingertips is indispensable.
These security features, coupled with a user-friendly interface and seamless integration, make Microsoft Entra ID an exhilarating solution for those of us who prioritize cloud security. It not only enhances our security posture but also empowers us to adapt and respond effectively to evolving cybersecurity challenges.
What needs improvement?
Privileged Identity Management (PIM) Performance: Improvements in the performance and reliability of PIM are crucial. Users occasionally encounter issues where roles are elevated, but the assigned roles do not function as expected. Enhancing the consistency and responsiveness of PIM is essential for a seamless privilege management experience.
Portal Speed and Responsiveness: Addressing occasional slowdowns, particularly on Fridays, within the Azure Entra ID portal is important. Consistent portal performance ensures efficient user access management and administration.
Cross-Tenant Synchronization and Collaboration: Simplifying cross-tenant synchronization and collaboration is essential for organizations working in multi-tenant environments. Enhancements in this area can streamline identity and access management processes across tenants, reducing complexity and improving collaboration.
User Offboarding and SharePoint Permissions: Streamlining the offboarding process for former employees is critical. After disabling or deleting a former employee's account, there should be an automatic mechanism to remove associated permissions in SharePoint. Currently, these permissions often remain in SharePoint as stale entries, requiring manual removal. Automating this process can improve security and reduce administrative overhead.
Buyer's Guide
Microsoft Entra ID
January 2025
Learn what your peers think about Microsoft Entra ID. Get advice and tips from experienced pros sharing their opinions. Updated: January 2025.
832,138 professionals have used our research since 2012.
For how long have I used the solution?
I have been using Microsoft Entra ID for six and a half years.
What do I think about the stability of the solution?
The Entra ID system has consistently demonstrated a high level of stability. Throughout our usage, I can't recall a single instance when the service experienced downtime. This underscores Microsoft's commitment to ensuring the continuous functionality of the service for its customers.
The stability of Entra ID is crucial for our operations, and its reliability has greatly contributed to our confidence in the platform. Microsoft's dedication to maintaining a stable environment aligns with the expectations of organizations relying on their services.
In summary, the stability of the Entra ID system has been commendable, and it reflects Microsoft's emphasis on delivering a reliable experience to its users.
What do I think about the scalability of the solution?
Scalability in the context of Entra ID has been a significant advantage, particularly when compared to traditional on-premises solutions. The scalability of Entra ID is dependent on both the hardware and the underlying infrastructure. In the case of on-premises servers, organizations are tasked with maintaining and upgrading the hardware, which can be resource-intensive.
What I've observed with Entra ID is that it offers exceptional scalability and reliability. This scalability is achieved through a combination of factors, including built-in redundancy and automatic updates. Microsoft takes on the responsibility of managing the underlying infrastructure, alleviating the maintenance burden on organizations.
This level of scalability allows us the flexibility to easily scale our resources up or down based on our specific requirements. Whether we need to accommodate growth or adjust resources to optimize costs, Entra ID provides the agility needed to achieve our goals.
In essence, the scalability of Entra ID is of the highest quality, and it's a testament to the benefits of utilizing a cloud solution like Azure. The cloud-based approach simplifies resource management and ensures that we can efficiently adapt to changing demands.
How are customer service and support?
We've encountered occasional issues, and Microsoft's customer service and support have consistently been friendly and responsive. Whenever we've reached out to them, they've promptly assisted us in resolving our problems.
One notable aspect is that Microsoft support typically prefers phone calls or emails for communication. While their support is effective, we've found that using Microsoft Teams for support calls would be much more convenient. Teams provides an efficient and collaborative platform for communication, making it a valuable tool for resolving issues.
This highlights the opportunity for Microsoft to enhance customer support by utilizing Teams for more convenient and efficient interactions.
How would you rate customer service and support?
How was the initial setup?
The initial setup of Entra ID is remarkably straightforward. The system seamlessly integrates within our existing infrastructure, requiring nothing more than an Azure tenant.
In terms of the migration process, we prioritize quality over quantity. We don't need a large workforce for the migration; instead, we value individuals who possess a clear understanding of their roles and responsibilities. This approach is supported by a well-established product line and effective risk management strategies. Additionally, our past experiences and insights gained from previous projects significantly contribute to our confidence and comprehension of the necessary actions.
In collaboration with our partners, our team consists of five members dedicated to the migration process. Our partners, on the other hand, have a smaller team comprising three individuals providing assistance. This collaborative effort ensures a smooth and efficient transition to Entra ID.
What about the implementation team?
We worked with a Cloud Solution Provider (CSP) with many years of experience with the product to successfully implement Entra ID
What was our ROI?
Our investment in Entra ID has undoubtedly yielded a significant return. Those familiar with its capabilities and accompanying features are confident in the tangible benefits it brings. In a landscape where cloud advancements have revolutionized IT, Entra ID stands out as a crucial component of our infrastructure.
Without this cloud product and the transformative developments in cloud technology, navigating the IT landscape would be challenging. We'd likely find ourselves exploring various products from different companies, potentially incurring higher costs than our current investment in Entra cloud products.
Therefore, I have full confidence that we've achieved a substantial return on investment through our adoption of Entra ID and other cloud solutions. It's a testament to the value and cost-efficiency that modern cloud technologies offer to organizations.
What's my experience with pricing, setup cost, and licensing?
When it comes to setup cost, pricing, and licensing for Entra ID, I would advise others to carefully assess their organization's specific needs and requirements. It's essential to have a clear understanding of the features and capabilities needed to support your business operations effectively.
Consider the scalability of your organization and how Entra ID aligns with your growth plans. Microsoft offers various licensing options, so it's worth exploring the most suitable licensing model that fits your budget and operational demands.
Additionally, keep in mind that while initial setup costs may vary, the long-term benefits of a secure and efficient identity management solution like Entra ID can significantly outweigh the initial investment. It's an investment in both security and productivity.
Lastly, stay updated with Microsoft's licensing updates and pricing changes to ensure that your organization remains compliant and optimized in terms of cost-effectiveness."
This advice provides a general guideline for organizations considering Entra ID, encouraging them to conduct a thorough evaluation of their needs and resources.
What other advice do I have?
Our organization has a strong Microsoft orientation, which naturally led us to align our infrastructure with Microsoft standards. Entra ID serves as our identity provider, handling crucial processes like onboarding, offboarding, and managing departed employees' accounts and devices.
One challenge we've encountered is dealing with "stale devices" connected to Entra ID when employees have left the company. To address this, we regularly execute scripts to identify and manage both dormant accounts and devices. Compliance policies, especially in countries like Germany, necessitate specific mailbox access rules for departed employees. This involves granting the manager access to the mailbox for three months before archiving it. Deleting the user account isn't an option in such cases.
Entra ID offers a health dashboard that helps us track maintenance activities and pending implementations. Key updates, recommended every three months by Microsoft, are currently performed on a monthly basis to maintain robust security.
As a multinational company and a global workforce, security is paramount. Multifactor authentication is a crucial process for all Entra ID users, given the increasing sophistication of cyber threats. We highly recommend exploring the security features of Entra ID and its integration with Azure Information Protection—a cost-effective, AI-driven solution that enhances security.
Which deployment model are you using for this solution?
Hybrid Cloud
If public cloud, private cloud, or hybrid cloud, which cloud provider do you use?
Microsoft Azure
Disclosure: I am a real user, and this review is based on my own experience and opinions.