GitHub Reviews

Name: GitHub
Brand: GitHub
Rating: 4 (87 reviews)

Vendor: GitHub

4.4 out of 5

87 reviews
100% willing to recommend

519 followers

Post review

What is GitHub?

GitHub is a web-based Git repository hosting service. It offers all of the distributed revision control and source code management (SCM) functionality of Git as well as adding its own features. Unlike Git, which is strictly a command-line tool, GitHub provides a Web-based graphical interface and desktop as well as mobile integration. It also provides access control and several collaboration features such as bug tracking, feature requests, task management, and wikis for every project.

Get the GitHub Buyer's Guide and find out what your peers are saying about GitHub, SonarQube Server (formerly SonarQube), Veracode and more!

GitHub is the #3 ranked solution in top Version Control solutions and #7 ranked solution in application security solutions. PeerSpot users give GitHub an average rating of 8.8 out of 10. Based on the analysis of the 87 most recent GitHub reviews, the overall sentiment is positive, with a sentiment score of 7.7. (Among the highest in the category). GitHub is most commonly compared to SonarQube Server (formerly SonarQube): GitHub vs SonarQube Server (formerly SonarQube). GitHub is popular among the large enterprise segment, accounting for 67% of users researching this solution on PeerSpot. The top industry researching this solution are professionals from a manufacturing company, accounting for 13% of all views.

Helped 814,649 peers since 2012

Featured reviews

AjayKrishna

Senior Software Engineer at a transportation company with 10,001+ employees

I think one area where GitHub could improve is its search and navigation functionality within repositories. For example, we use IDEs like IntelliJ or Visual Studio Code when developing code. These IDEs allow us to easily navigate from one piece of code to another file where a method is being called. It would be really helpful if the solution could add this navigation feature. It would allow us to move from one class file to another more easily, helping us search quicker and follow the code flow completely within GitHub. This would be more convenient than having to import the code into our local IDE to look at the code flow and navigate through it. Adding this kind of IDE-like navigation within the tool would make the user experience more seamless and efficient.

Read full review

PeterKrall

Freelance Software Engineer + Director of a company at Peter Krall Consulting

Speaking of what can be made better in a solution is a difficult topic to discuss because it is not just technology. The tool could improve in the area of artificial intelligence methods. Recently, I made an error when I recently worked on a project since I was confused with some things, and it took quite some work to get it fixed again. Some kind of support in the area of merging should be considered for improvement. At the moment, any improvements in the aforementioned area would be something that I would appreciate as a user. Specifically, I want the solution to offer AI-based merging support, as it is the only area where the product has certain shortcomings.

Read full review

Chinmay Banerjee

Advisor Adtech/Martech/API product/project Engineering at Fiserv

With fourteen years of experience with the product, I don't think I would face any challenges with it. For new users, it would be good if they could gather a detailed overview to understand the solution, and they could get information from YouTube or other social media platforms. I suggest that new users learn how to manage the product's setup phase. It is better to indulge in some self-study and do the homework, and parallelly consider using the support system offered by GitHub to learn about the product. I have an experience with one of the Big Four companies, EY, where GitHub is used frequently. I have already recommended the product to multiple clients, including PepsiCo, Kellog, Procter & Gamble, Bank of America, and Citibank. Sometimes, you have to manage all your codes locally, but it would be great to have everything managed on the cloud. As my company has been managing codes with GitHub for a long time, I always practice with the tool and get trained to figure out good ways in which certain things can be done with the product. I feel that there is a need to encourage people to use the product, and it can be a healthy thing since it will be possible for people in an organization to delete the local file once someone leaves the company, and it can be done at a global level. My company plans to start the AI development project in one of the upcoming quarters. GitHub is the technical platform from which we cannot expect more, but we can race a request with the support team and tell them about our company's expectations and inform them that we need their help to deal with the AI model in the solution. If my organization plans to use the AI part, I cannot force GitHub to help me, but I will check to the extent to which I can receive help from the tool's support team. If I am developing some new model with the help of AI, then it is my responsibility to bridge the gap by considering factors at a solution level. I believe in always going for an approach involving a handshake with the technology partners and service partners. During the initial days of usage, there won't be any cost savings possible with GitHub. I rate the solution a nine and a half out of ten.

Read full review

GitHub mindshare

Product category:

As of November 2024, the mindshare of GitHub in the Version Control category stands at 5.5%, down from 7.8% compared to the previous year, according to calculations based on PeerSpot user engagement data.

Version Control

Key learnings from peers

Last updated Nov 1, 2024

Valuable Features

GitHub features highly valued by users include community support, Git Hooks, SSH keys, source code management, task automation, code versioning, scalability, and stability. Other appreciated aspects are seamless integration with tools like Jenkins and Azure, ease of branching, pull requests for code reviews, advanced security, and accessibility from anywhere. Users also find the platform user-friendly and cost-effective, enjoying its excellent collaboration capabilities and comprehensive action systems for automation.

"GitHub is very straightforward. I really appreciate the versioning capabilities, ease of use, and the ability to host code."
"GitHub is easy, secure, and widely documented."
"The most valuable features are the speed, low latency, and the clear, concise set of commands."

Room for Improvement

Users highlight that GitHub requires improvements in security features, interface usability, speed for large file handling, integration with tools like Slack, Jenkins, and CI/CD capabilities. They also seek better project management functionalities, more intuitive navigation, enhanced merging processes, and support for languages such as Arabic. Additionally, the learning curve and onboarding process should be streamlined for non-technical users. Stability, AI integration, and expanded storage are also desired enhancements.

"The integration with Visual Studio Code could be more streamlined."
"GitHub could automate the setup process more, such as creating YAML files for GitHub Actions."
"There is nothing that I find that needs improvement in GitHub."

ROI

GitHub delivers substantial time savings, leading to financial benefits through efficient code management and version control. Companies enjoy secure code, streamlined feature releases, and effective migration across computers. They experience cost savings as usage increases within teams and appreciate improved organization that minimizes disputes. While initial use may not yield immediate savings, value becomes apparent with broader adoption, even if some access it without direct investment.

Pricing

GitHub offers a versatile pricing model suitable for different needs. The free version supports public repositories, but private and enterprise features require a license. Many organizations cite GitHub as cost-effective, with an annual subscription model providing good value. However, managing licenses can be complex, especially with team changes. The solution is popular for its affordability compared to competitors, with options for paid support. Organizations appreciate its open-source foundation with additional commercial packages available.

"I think, in terms of price, GitHub is okay compared to other tools."
"Regarding pricing, I'd rate it eight out of ten. It's decent and not too expensive, and small businesses can also afford it. With AWS taking CodeCommit out of the market, I don't see many competitors for small companies in terms of GitHub."
"GitHub is a cost-effective solution."

Popular Use Cases

GitHub is primarily used for version control, source code management, and collaboration. Users utilize GitHub to manage code repositories, track changes, and handle branching and merging strategies. It serves as a centralized platform for developers to store, share, and review code. Organizations integrate GitHub with tools like CI/CD pipelines and use it for documentation, testing, and application development. Its cloud-based nature benefits users with immediate access and synchronization capabilities.

Service and Support

Many users find GitHub's technical support responsive and helpful, while others rarely need direct assistance due to the platform's user-friendliness and extensive community resources. Some mention monthly consultations with knowledgeable technical sales teams. A few express dissatisfaction with response times. The community support is highly valued, often providing quick solutions without needing official support. Overall satisfaction varies, with some rating GitHub's technical support positively, while others find improvements necessary.

Deployment

GitHub's initial setup is generally straightforward and simple. Many users find it easy, taking only a few minutes to complete. Some mention difficulty when dealing with specific IDE integrations. Private repositories add complexity due to security needs. It offers numerous integration opportunities and requires minimal maintenance. Most users experience a smooth start, with ease in creating repositories and teams. Beginners may benefit from online guidance and documentation.

Scalability

Users consistently find GitHub highly scalable, managing thousands of users and extensive repositories without issues. Numerous organizations report seamless operations and hassle-free expansion. Users appreciate scalability, ease of adding members, and cloud-based benefits. Even large deployments with significant user bases experience minimal performance disruptions. Some report minor challenges due to team dynamics rather than platform limitations. Overall, adaptability and robust features contribute to its positive reception among diverse enterprises worldwide.

Stability

Users generally find GitHub highly stable, with very few issues reported. Many highlight its reliable performance, absence of bugs, and consistent uptime. It supports over a thousand daily users without crashes or freezes. Some users rate its stability between seven to ten out of ten, noting minor issues under heavy workloads. Constant updates enhance its stability, while availability and performance remain strong. Reliability is noted across various company sizes and complex use cases.

These insights are based on the in-depth reviews provided by peers to help you make a better buying decision.

Download our GitHub Buyer's Guide for additional reliable information.