What is our primary use case?
Our company uses the solution for perimeter security. We are distributors in the Middle East and Africa. We look for competitive analysis against Fortinet and Sophos.
What is most valuable?
The price versus value is good because the solution is less expensive than Sophos, Fortinet, or SonicWall.
What needs improvement?
The interface and user experience are horrible. To perform simple things, you need to jump between many screens. There is no simplicity, everything is complex.
The available information is lacking. I'm struggling to give my coworker information about how to configure. The public information available is too old and hasn't been updated.
The solution is not out-of-the-box because it requires a mandatory license.
Outside of China, the solution does not offer active-active, virtual domains, or concurrent sessions. The CCB or UTB sessions and BPM channels are very low. The solution is a Chinese product and that side is different from the rest of the world. China has version 8.0.59 but the rest of the world has 8.0.47 only.
The solution has very, very slow hardware performance.
For how long have I used the solution?
I have been using the solution for one year.
What do I think about the stability of the solution?
The solution is stable so I rate stability an nine out of ten.
What do I think about the scalability of the solution?
The solution is not really scalable because it is limited by the capability of the box. You cannot scale out or up because there are hardware limitations.
Scalability is rated a zero out of ten.
How are customer service and support?
In Asia, technical support is good but it is very weak in our region. When you are looking for information from technical support, it will take ages for them to respond but chances are good that they won't respond at all.
Even presale support is not good.
I rate support a two out of ten.
How would you rate customer service and support?
How was the initial setup?
The setup is complex because the interface is not good.
For someone who is already a professional with another product, the setup is rated a five out of ten. For someone with security experience only, the setup is rated a one out of ten.
What about the implementation team?
We implemented the solution in-house. One experienced person can deploy.
Setup for someone who is experienced with other products will take a day for configuration.
Someone who knows security but doesn't know other products like Fortinet, Sophos, or SonicWall will struggle. It takes days to fetch out between sequences and you have to jump between screens for things like ABI, email security, and DLP. It takes time to figure out the proper sequence.
What's my experience with pricing, setup cost, and licensing?
The solution has a total cost of ownership that is 32% to 50% less than Sophos, Fortinet, and SonicWall. Licenses are also less expensive than Sophos.
The solution is not out-of-the box because a license is mandatory. You cannot operate the device by itself. This makes no sense because you should be able to use the default features or operate it without a license. Even if the device is capable, you still need a license.
The four categories of licenses are features, hardware, software updates or technical support, and advanced features. The vendor insists it is mandatory to buy the minimum features license. This license mandate is very strange.
The solution might raise its prices because Fortinet is increasing between 5% to 20% depending on the product and the solution competes with Fortinet. If the leader in the industry increases prices, other vendors will likely follow.
The pricing right now is an eight out of ten because it is good.
Which other solutions did I evaluate?
Fortinet is one of the best products so I recommend its use instead. There is continuous development and good R&D for the product.
What other advice do I have?
I would not recommend use of the solution at all. There has not been one single improvement or feature update in the last year. The solution is very bad at R&D.
The solution also keeps changing names and product positioning. It used to be called Butler, then Cloud Platforms.
There is not a single Sangfor employee right now outside of China who can give an explanation of their products. They don't know how the products even work. For example, they can't explain who can book the NGAF with Neural-X, with Engine Zero, or with a Platform-X or Butler cyber command.
I rate the solution a four out of ten.
Which deployment model are you using for this solution?
On-premises