IBM DOORS and Jira are competing in the field of requirements and project management tools. IBM DOORS seems to have the upper hand with robust capabilities for managing complex requirements, although Jira is favored for agile project management with its strong integration features.
Features: IBM DOORS offers traceability, impact analysis, and history baselining. It provides extensive customization through the DOORS Extension Language (DXL). These features make it ideal for large-scale projects. Jira is renowned for its issue tracking and workflow management and its wide range of third-party integrations. It’s versatile, especially within agile environments.
Room for Improvement: IBM DOORS faces challenges with integration and a steep learning curve, alongside usability concerns. Its proprietary database also limits flexibility. Jira struggles with complex customization and performance issues, particularly during scaling. Its reporting capabilities and user experience could be enhanced.
Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: IBM DOORS is mainly deployed on-premises with varying customer service quality. Noteworthy improvements have been made recently, although technical support can sometimes be stretched thin. Jira is flexible, offering cloud-based and on-premises deployment. It is generally appreciated for responsive customer support, although more direct interaction with Atlassian is desired by some users.
Pricing and ROI: IBM DOORS is considered expensive, often justified by its comprehensive feature set for large enterprises. Jira offers more economical pricing for smaller setups, but costs can rise with additional plugins. Both tools yield high ROI for large-scale implementations, but Jira's adaptability is more beneficial for smaller, agile teams.
IBM Engineering Requirements Management DOORS (DOORS) is a Requirements Management (RM) software designed to help organizations manage engineering project requirements throughout the development lifecycle. It provides a central location for capturing, defining, and organizing project requirements, facilitating communication and collaboration among stakeholders like engineers, system designers, and customers. Key features include requirements traceability, version control, and impact analysis, ensuring effective implementation and testing. DOORS improves efficiency, enhances communication, reduces risks, and supports better decision-making through clear visibility into requirements. Compared to its newer, web-based counterpart DOORS Next, the mature DOORS 9 offers a wider range of features with a traditional user interface but lacks web-based functionality and modern integration with IBM Engineering Lifecycle Management (ELM) tools.
Jira is a powerful cloud- and subscription-based application lifecycle and issue management solution. It is designed to aid users both in project management and in resolving any issues that arise at any point in the software development process. It is especially concerned with easing the ability of developers to collaborate.
Jira Benefits
Some of the ways that organizations can benefit by choosing to deploy Jira include:
Jira Features
Real-time notification feature. Users can set Jira so that it offers them notifications that contain critical information in real time. It can send users email notifications when pressing issues have been updated. They can also set it to notify them about tasks that may be due, or other similar events.
Reviews from Real Users
Jira is a powerful solution that stands out when compared to many of its competitors. Two major advantages it offers are its workflow engine and its highly customizable dashboard.
Bharath R., the tool implementation and project management lead at a financial services firm, writes, “I feel the strongest feature of Jira is its workflow engine. It empowers us to automate our workflows within our organization. It's the one characteristic of Jira which I think can help any organization, be it in any domain.”
Uday J., a staff engineer at a computer company, says, “Another thing that I like a lot about Jira is that in the dashboard, you can plug the modules that you want. You can enable certain sections. For example, you can show trend history, open Jira tickets, etc. Some of the managers have created a dashboard for each engineer.”
We monitor all Application Requirements Management reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.
